Dr. John Crescitelli

Absolutely. Here’s a strong but more polished version that keeps your firsthand experience and makes the criticism clear without sounding overly emotional:

⭐ 1-Star Review

I was a new patient and unfortunately my first experience with Dr. John Crescitelli was extremely disappointing and unprofessional.

Dr. Crescitelli was about an hour late to my appointment. The ladies at the front desk were very polite and repeatedly told me that he would be there in “five more minutes,” but those five minutes eventually turned into an hour of sitting and waiting. The only reason I didn’t leave was because the front-desk staff were so kind and genuinely tried their best to keep me comfortable while I waited.

When Dr. Crescitelli finally arrived, he did not come directly into my room, and there was no apology or acknowledgment for keeping me waiting for an hour. What I witnessed when he eventually came in was also extremely unprofessional and left a very poor first impression.

Once the appointment began, I found that he talked excessively and went on and on, making the appointment much longer than necessary. I left feeling that a significant amount of my time had been wasted.

I have seen other reviews saying that Dr. Crescitelli knows his stuff, and perhaps he does. However, knowledge alone does not excuse being consistently late, failing to respect patients’ time, and behaving unprofessionally. A doctor can be knowledgeable and still provide a poor patient experience.

I would much rather spend 10–15 minutes waiting at a doctor’s office where my time is respected than spend $2,300 and have my entire morning consumed by an appointment that starts an hour late.

I also overheard comments from the front-desk staff suggesting that he might be sleeping, which only added to my concerns about the lack of punctuality and organization.

As a new patient, this experience was enough for me to decide that this was not the right doctor or practice for me. I ultimately chose to take my business elsewhere.

If you value punctuality, professionalism, and respect for your time, I personally would not recommend Dr. Crescitelli based on my experience.

If I could give no stars, I certainly would.
I would not recommend Dr. Crescitelli, especially if you value punctuality and respect for your time.

In my experience, appointments were frequently delayed, and there were also last-minute reschedules. Getting an early 9:00 AM appointment was difficult because he was often running behind schedule. I have spent an hour waiting to be seen, only for the appointment to be delayed even further.

When Dr. Crescitelli finally came into the room, he would sometimes spend another 20 minutes talking with his staff before addressing me. Once the appointment actually started, it could last well over an hour, with a significant amount of the conversation focused on topics that were not related to my health or medical concerns.

I understand that medical appointments can sometimes run behind, but the repeated delays, last-minute scheduling changes, and amount of time spent waiting became extremely frustrating. I felt that my time was not being respected.

Because of these experiences, I ultimately decided to leave the practice. If you are someone who has a busy schedule or needs a doctor who is reliable and respectful of your appointment time, I would not recommend this practice based on my experience.

Absolutely the best! I have been through so many doctors in the past few years, well, I say doctors, heck most office you never actually see the doctor. Dr. C is amazing, so glad I found him! Ones like him you just can't find anymore. Honestly, he is the best. Also has an awesome staff!

Dr Crescitelli is the best doctor that I have ever been seen by. There have been several occasions where I have had problems at odd off office hours, and he did not hesitate to help me and give me the care that I needed. He is extremely knowledgeable and has helped to not only keep me alive, but keep me feeling well. I highly recommend him.

I have been going to Dr. Crescitelli for 20 years. There is no better. He is thorough to a fault. He goes out of his way to make sure that nothing is sneaking up on you. He will sit and talk with you and examine you and find out everything. He loves being a healer and a doctor. I have spoken to him numerous times in the evening, and he is still at the office going over his patience files to make sure everything is addressed and nothing is missed. The beauty of the concierge Service is he is available 24/7. As I get older, being 62 My health becomes more serious than it was when I was young. The fact that he knows what to look for and truly cares is comforting. He got away from the corporate world of medicine And became just old school hands-on healing with no bureaucracy. Thank you, Dr. John, for always having my best interest in your heart.

Dr. John Crescitelli is truly a doctor’s doctor—brilliant, thoughtful, and an exceptional diagnostician. He combines tremendous clinical judgment with genuine empathy, patience, and an ability to really listen to his patients. I have enormous confidence in his judgment and would recommend him without hesitation to family, friends, and colleagues. He represents the very best of what a physician should be.

Dr. Crescitelli is phenomenal Primary Care Physician. He’s very thorough and the type of doctor you want to manage your entire healthcare. He is by far the best doctor I’ve ever seen for over 28 years. His staff is also excellent and very responsive. Every visit is a great experience!

Dr John has been my doctor for two years plus now. I signed up with MD VIP after sitting in two separate doctors offices, trying to find a primary care physician for over an hour before anybody even came to see me. When I made my appointment with Dr. Jon they saw me on time and I can’t believe I spent all those years sitting in doctors offices waiting just to be seen. John is warm, affable, and an all-around good guy. His exams are thorough and he goes that extra level to follow up and make sure that the results are meaningful from every test and that I understand what I’m seeing. His office staff is great. I don’t think I’ve ever waited more than five minutes to see anybody. If I’m out of town and something is wrong, I can text him or call him and he always picks up. He immediately treats my concerns as if they were his own. I would recommend Dr. John wholeheartedly.

Dr. Crescitelli is a a highly knowledgeable and compassionate Doctor. His understanding of medicine is of remarkable breadth and as is his concern and care for his patients. I highly recommend him. You will be in good hands.....

I’ve was going to the same Primary doctor for years, very close to home and convenient, until I started having health issues and I felt I needed a change as I wasn’t getting the care I wanted or needed.
My husband has known and been going to Dr Crescitelli for years, prior to MDVIP and now with MDVIP. I finally decided to follow him and start my health journey with Dr Crescitelli, MDVIP, for my Primary doctor. This has been the BEST decision I have made since saying yes to marry my husband 36 years ago.
The first phone call to the office was excellent with Ryan (spelling) Tammie and Robert running the office, I felt like I found my new home.
The MDVIP experience is like nothing I have ever experienced. First a sit and chat with the doc, which I do warn you Doc loves to explain everything so you can’t be in a hurry. Then I continued to part 1, which involved a bunch of in office testing from eyes, ears, body mass, strength of my goodness I can’t list everything that was done. Onto the COMPLETE blood work up and then part 2 follow up to sit with doc to go over ALL the tests, once again plan on a lengthy visit.
Dr Crescitelli researched and searched to resolve my health issues and I feel great knowing I have this amazing team guiding me towards a healthy future.

A doctor who listens and gives good advice from years of knowledge

My husband and I have been his parents for 3 years now. We have been amazed by his attention to detail and his willingness to listen to his patients. His dedication to his profession, patients and staff are inspiring. He has a unique ability to make you feel like you occupy the entirety of his attention during your visits. We wholeheartedly would and have recommended him to several of our friends.

If you are looking for a doctor who listens and works to coordinate your care with all of your other doctors, Dr Crescitelli is the doctor you been wishing for. He thoughtfully provides full exams and is fully skilled to provide answers.

In addition, appointments are easily made and the office staff and nurses are extremely friendly and helpful.

Dr. Crescitelli is an incredible doctor. Excellent skills, a wealth of knowledge, compassion, empathy, and an honest interest in his patients. He is never rushed and will work you in if there is a critical medical issue. I highly recommend him. David L. Webb

he is a wonderful physician. very knowledgeable and emits a friendly and caring environment, and makes sure you understand what he is talking about.

Great doctor and human being. He knows what he is doing! takes his time and goes every detail with you.

Had appointment on Aug 7th.
The Doctor didn’t show up. Dr Crescitelli called me after I got home. Said he was at the hospital seeing a patient. Giving 1 star because his office staff is nice